Some thoughts that came to my mind while reading the replies: -Brain brought a good point about dev people being more knowledgeable when it comes to hacks and such -Like I said, and someone else did too, like every zone forum, it has a staff forum... However, I suggest that most discussions should happen in the public discussion board to gather player advice and such. Only some more sensitive issues should be discussed in private... and even then, a summary once in a while of what was discussed, decisions taken, etc. should be made in the public section. Even if the issue is very sensitive, like 'how to deal with hack X', you could summarize it with 'we discussed on how to deal with some hack.' Hmm, well Sketter's post went pretty much in the same direction as this So yeah... Basically, don't split it with what the players need to view and what they don't need to; split it with what they 'CAN' see, and what they CAN'T see. Even if players don't give a !@#$%^&* about a specific issue, as long as it's not sensitive like something about hacks or bans, they 'can' view it, and it should be public. However, make sure to put a warning that the topics will be moderated, anything offtopic would be sent to the shredder